Trade secrets create a difficult economic boundary in regulated business-to-business data access. A data holder cannot simply convert every existing confidentiality expense into a new fee, while a recipient should not receive sensitive information without proportionate safeguards. The EU Data Act has applied since 12 September 2025. Article 9 addresses reasonable, non-discriminatory compensation in qualifying B2B sharing; Article 5 contains trade-secret protections in relevant access situations. The European Commission explains both access rights and their limitations. The framework below is a practical costing illustration, not legal advice or a statement that all datasets fall under mandatory sharing.
Identify the exact legal access pathway
Begin by asking why the recipient is entitled to receive data. A voluntarily negotiated marketplace license differs from mandatory access arising under a particular Data Act chapter or separate sectoral rule. Record the data holder, user, recipient, connected product or service, requested categories and permitted purpose. The definition and scope of a trade secret require legal analysis rather than a unilateral checkbox. Do not presume that a database containing commercially valuable information is entirely exempt from every obligation.
Maintain a scope sheet with legal basis, data-field inventory, claimed secrecy rationale, permitted purpose and reviewer. If the access pathway is uncertain, seek qualified advice before quoting an access charge or refusing delivery.
Separate baseline protection from incremental disclosure
A seller probably already uses encryption, staff access restrictions, incident response and security monitoring to protect its own business. Those standing controls exist independently of a particular request. Distinguish them from recipient-specific work: a dedicated access channel, tailored confidentiality terms, identity verification or a bespoke redaction process. The separation avoids describing ordinary internal security as a unique service sold to each new recipient. It also helps explain why a protective measure is necessary and proportionate.
Example ledger: baseline annual security operations of $60,000 stay in the internal operating budget. A request-specific two-hour review and restricted delivery environment costing an illustrative $280 are separately documented; whether recoverable is a legal question.
Model the recipient’s burden separately
The data recipient may incur staff training, segregation, local encryption and access-review costs after receipt. They should not be invisibly folded into the holder’s fee. A practical negotiation records duties on both sides, then asks which party performs and funds each control. A data intermediary can lower duplication but introduces another trust boundary. Test access termination and breach response before agreeing that the intermediary is cheaper.
Build a two-column ledger: holder-specific incremental control and recipient-side safeguard. Add the responsible controller, retention period and expected verification evidence. This prevents a low headline access fee from hiding large implementation obligations.
Use Article 9 carefully in a price discussion
For B2B compensation within Article 9, the regulation emphasizes reasonableness and non-discrimination, including costs of making data available and, where applicable, production investment. It also places special limitations in specified SME and non-profit research situations. That does not mean every seller can add an unrestricted trade-secret premium or that a draft guidance document is binding law. The 2026 Commission consultation on reasonable compensation was a draft consultation, not a blanket price table.
Compare hypothetical offers for a large enterprise and a qualifying SME under the same delivery facts. Flag differences attributable to applicable statutory constraints, objective cost changes and unsupported assumptions. Escalate rather than guess.
Design safeguards that can be demonstrated
The parties should agree on the exact measures before delivery: identity-bound credentials, least-privilege access, technical restrictions where appropriate, audit evidence and rapid revocation. A signed non-disclosure agreement alone cannot ensure that a downstream copy disappears. Conversely, intrusive monitoring of recipients may create unnecessary privacy or competition concerns. The goal is a proportionate control set tied to the particular risk, not maximum surveillance.
Exercise: simulate an authorized download, attempted redistribution and contract expiration. Keep timestamps, permission decisions and closure evidence without publicly exposing the underlying trade-secret data. Retest when the sharing purpose changes.
Publish an auditable compensation worksheet
An illustrative worksheet has three separate lines: a documented disclosure service cost, a recipient-specific security increment and any permitted commercial component under the applicable rule. Add assumptions, payer, scope and review date. Do not combine independent data licensing revenue with mandatory-access compensation in one ambiguous field. A neutral audit trail can support negotiations if a buyer disputes the allocation.
Scenario: delivery handling $160, dedicated access-control work $90 and negotiated recurring review $45 yield $295 of modeled work. This is not a legal entitlement to recover $295; eligibility, allocation and reasonableness require separate assessment.
Decision rule. Finndy’s practical conclusion is a two-ledger discipline: map rights and secrecy separately from the economics of making a specific disclosure. Quote only after the legal pathway and safeguards are documented, use transparent assumptions, and review Commission guidance for later changes. Protecting secrets and enabling lawful data reuse are compatible when every cost and control has an identifiable purpose.
Sources and source dates
- Regulation (EU) 2023/2854, Data Act, Articles 5 and 9 (2023)
- European Commission Data Act explanation (applies since 2025-09-12)
- European Commission consultation on draft reasonable compensation guidelines (2026-02-02)
Image: Unsplash, illustrative editorial use. All scenario amounts are explicit assumptions, not audited market benchmarks.
